Please Note: To successfully submit this form, your browser must be set up to send email.
If you prefer, you may print this form or download the text version and work on it in the program of your choice, eg. Word, Word Perfect, etc. When finished, fax or mail it to:
Geological Association of Canada, Publications Team
Department of Earth Sciences
Room ER4063, Alexander Murray Building
Memorial University of Newfoundland
St. John's, NL A1B 3X5 CANADA
We seek your view of the scientific merit and quality of preparation of this manuscript. These questions are not meant to be comprehensive but are used to illustrate the type of questions to consider during review of the manuscript.
A few guidelines:
- To provide the author(s) with the means to improve their paper, please comment objectively. On a separate sheet you may provide additional comment for the editor, keying the remarks to letters A to S.
- If a paper repeats previously published work, please point this out to the editor.
- Considering the effort that is put into a review, and its value to the recipients, please keep a copy until its safe arrival at the editor’s office is confirmed.